Carnival & Booth GamesNo. 1250 · The 2026 edition
Witches Brew Halloween Game
Test your tossing skills with this spooky cauldron toss game where players aim to fill the witches' brew with stuffed frogs!
Our own summary of the original — the full post and photos live at carnivalsavers.com.
Set up three witch cauldrons and a throwing line marked with glowing pumpkins. Players take turns tossing three stuffed frogs into the cauldrons in order from closest to farthest. Anyone who lands a frog in each cauldron wins a top Halloween prize.
You'll need
Directions
- Arrange the three cauldrons or black kettles together as a group.
- Insert an LED underwater light into each mini plastic pumpkin, then line them up to mark where players stand and throw from.
- Give each player three stuffed frogs (or plush bats) to toss.
- The challenge is to toss the frogs into the cauldrons in sequence—first the nearest, then the middle, and finally the farthest.
- Anyone who successfully lands one frog in each of the three cauldrons wins a top prize from the Halloween prize collection.
More photos
Photos hosted by carnivalsavers.com.
